
Before I start, allow me to express my sadness and compassion to Roy’s family. I know there are no words that would help, but I am glad the suspects have been arrested, and look forward to seeing them pay the price for the horrible crime they have committed.
When the Death Penalty Fever in Lebanon Flares Up
It’s maybe normal to feel the urge for revenge after horrible events happen to someone in Lebanon. Who among us wouldn’t love it if a horrible person dies horribly as justice for what they’ve done? The question is though, who will succumb to that visceral urge for revenge, and who will make the decision to never kill as a society, no matter what, but punish the irredeemables and try to rehabilitate ones with lesser crimes.
Every time a case like Roy’s, or Sara’s, or any of the amazing young men and women we have lost so often in Lebanon for the most unacceptable of reasons, that should never result in someone’s death.
I asked on Twitter where people stood on the death penalty, and at the time of writing this post, it was an even 60% against, and 40% for.
https://twitter.com/GinoRaidy/status/872815445321166850
I am in the against camp, no matter what, and here’s why
Killing is Wrong
Absolutely no circumstance makes it ok to kill another person. Self-defense isn’t premeditated murder, and when someone kills in self-defense, they do not intend to murder, just to protect themselves. It’s absolutely not the same like calmly, years later, killing someone as a society.
Execution Doesn’t Deter Crime
No one thinks, “oh, damn, I don’t wanna get the death penalty, I’m not gonna kill this person! But if it was just life behind bars, sure, I’d go murder people and nothing would deter me!”. Come on. And if you’re still skeptical, every study made demonstrates there is absolutely no deterrent force as a result of executions. It just doesn’t affect if people will murder or not.
It Doesn’t Help the Victims’ Families
Aside from the “revenge killings” and “honor crimes” people, no one in their right mind would think killing someone else would bring them any sort of relief. It’s easy to yell for blood being spilt when you’re not directly affected by a crime, but trust me, if someone you love has been killed, the last thing that would quiet your grief is killing the person. Justice does, and there is no worse punishment than the rest of your life in a Lebanese prison.
When the State Kills, We Kill
When the state executes someone, the state includes you. Most people that are part of the state are not ok with their representative authorities killing someone. This is a deep question, and not one that’s case by case or crime by crime. Either we decide as a society to not include killing in our justice system, or we decide to kill some to appease a perverse sense of vigilante justice.
Judicial Reform is What Lebanon Needs
You’re a terrorist piece of shit that beheaded Lebanese soldiers and killed innocent civilians. You are the worst of the worst. A government official’s car is sent to pick you up from prison, and you’re free. In your arrest, you managed to kill a Lebanese police officer. The real massive issue here isn’t that you weren’t executed, it’s that a political leader got you out of jail, despite your heinous crimes and a martyr from Lebanon’s police force.
The answer to that isn’t killing criminals. It’s making sure that politicians who try to help criminals escape justice and their sentences, get sentences of their own and go to jail to join whoever they were trying to get off the hook.
Giving the excuse that our politicians are too corrupt and will always bail out really bad guys, so that’s why we need to kill criminals, is absolutely fucking insane, and unbelievably stupid.
Killing is wrong. Lebanon should never bring back the death penalty.
Lebanon technically still didn’t officially abolish the death penalty, however, no crime has a mandatory death sentence since 2001, which basically means the courts never have to execute anyone, and thus haven’t since 2004. In other words, Lebanon has de-facto abolished the death penalty, and if anything, we need to remove the possibility altogether, not reinstate it as mandatory.
As for politicians who use terrible crimes to rile up the crowd with calls for death penalty returning, you should be ashamed of yourselves for making use of a family’s grief to rile up your base.


























